History, politics, people of Oly WA

Category: Washington Politics (Page 18 of 27)

So, who’s to say that the parties can’t live with Top Two?

Depending on how the Supreme Court rules in the next few months, we might have a Top Two primary back in Washington. This could take the power away from local parties as to who actually carries their label, who gets considered a Democrat or Republican on the ballot.

Right now, that label is determined by a primary election choosing the parties’ nominees. But, in a system where two Dems could advance to the general, we could see parties using lawsuits and party conventions to enforce their label.

Side note: even if the Supreme Court upholds the lower court decision throwing out the Top Two, the Grange has said they’d consider a statewide non-partisan election initiative.

Anyway, the recent decisions by the Pierce County Democratic and Republican parties relating to how candidates will appear on the IRV ballot next year could give an indication how the parties could live in a Top Two or non-partisan world. Both parties are allowing more than one candidate to appear on the IRV ballot, the Democrats allowing three, Republicans two.

Letter to the TNT (hat tip to Ranked Choice Voting Washington):

Republicans decided to allow anyone who garners 40 percent-plus of delegate votes at the party’s county convention to run with their brand name. In theory, the party will have a maximum of two candidates for any of the countywide seats. In practice, it will propose one GOP candidate for each race.

The Democratic Party, in contrast, decided to allow an inclusive measure that would allow up to three party candidates per race. In practice, this means that voters will have a chance to decide, based on the merits of each candidate, to actually rank candidates based on their own values and agendas.

IRV is essentially a non-partisan system, as it relates to local parties. Each of them will allow more than one candidate to leave an internal party event (caucuses or a convention) with a nod and a label.

So, who’s to say that the two parties can’t live with Top Two?

Hating the caucuses (as a process) 2

I don’t like to write the same post twice, but this was just too perfect. An email from Dwight Pelz just now:

And the winner in Iowa is…

The winner in Iowa will be the families of the men and women serving in Iraq. The winner in Iowa will be our planet, suffering from the neglect of a Republican administration. The winner in Iowa will be the children of families who cannot afford health care in George Bush’s America.

Of course, not the actual men and women serving in Iraq, since they can’t participate in Iowa:

Jason Huffman has lived in Iowa his whole life. Lately he has been watching presidential debates on the Internet, discussing what he sees with friends and relatives. But when fellow Iowans choose among presidential candidates on Thursday night, he will not be able to vote, because he is serving with the National Guard in western Afghanistan.

“Shouldn’t we at least have as much influence in this as any other citizen?” Captain Huffman wrote in an e-mail interview.

He is far from the only Iowan who will not be able to participate. Because the caucuses, held in the early evening, do not allow absentee voting, they tend to leave out nearly entire categories of voters: the infirm, soldiers on active duty, medical personnel who cannot leave their patients, parents who do not have baby sitters, restaurant employees on the dinner shift, and many others who work in retail, at gas stations and in other jobs that require evening duty.

Hating the caucuses (as a process)

Bad for Iowa, bad for Washington.

Kos:

… this ridiculous process he defends will disenfranchises thousands of Iowans as it disenfranchises millions of voters around the country who would like a chance to vote for their favorite primary candidate but will never get the chance.

Future Majority:

To ad insult to injury, only a whopping 6% of Iowans manage to drag their asses out to participate in a given year. Even with an average of 49% turnout (in 2004), young voters can’t catch a break in the media narrative. Yet somehow Iowans get a big fat pat on the back from the media every four years because a few die-hards manage to drag themselves out to the caucus and it makes for great copy and even better economics for the state.

Though, six percent compares favorably to the 2 percent turnout for caucuses we get in Washington.

New York Times:

“It disenfranchises certain voters or makes them make choices between putting food on the table and caucusing,” said Tom Lindsey, a high school teacher in Iowa City. Mr. Lindsey plans to attend this year, but his neighbors include a cook who cannot slip away from his restaurant job on Thursday night and a mother who must care for her autistic child.

In Washington, I’m wondering how long we have to be left defending caucuses and designed low participation.

A party of the caucus, for the caucus and because of the caucus (crap)

Noemie has a very comprehensive post up at Washblog about the upcoming precinct caucuses. She rehashes for a bit the fight last year to try for a primary instead of a caucus, and puts forward some of the arguments for the caucus.

One I find troubling:

Washington State Democratic Party Chair Dwight Pelz has said that the caucus system encourages grassroots democracy and dialogue while the primary favors candidates who spend the most money on TV ads and teaches participants that politics is a solitary process. I agree.

Prior to this, Noemie (full disclosure: I like and admire Noemie) argues that we have to look at the caucuses in the context of our fully screwed up election system. Granted, caucuses are a lot better than much of what goes on.

But, I’d argue that caucuses (while usually a good thing) are being used cynically by the Washington State Democratic Party to:

a) drive down participation, and
b) recruit volunteers for the nine months before the election.

Yes, caucuses are great because they require and encourage active participation. But, the party is using that participation for its own use. And, after the election, the scores of jazzed, encouraged people will be dropped like a wet rag by the party because the job will be done at that point.

If the party was actually all about the participatory democracy, it would hold caucuses for every election. We hold a state primary for every other less sexy election in this state because the party would much rather have the state government pay for its winnowing down election than to have to pay for a caucus no one will show up to.

Here are some old posts from Washblog of mine arguing about caucuses and such:
Republicans were trying to make a point with primary vote
More Caucuses v. Primary
Caucus v. Primary debate keeps attention off the real problem: lack of participation

Here’s my favorite line:

But, the problem with caucuses is that very few people actually do turn out for them. On the other hand, the problem with primaries is that still very few people turn out for them. The Olympian editorial points out that while only two percent turn out for caucuses in a given year (certainly not in 2004), but 42 percent turn out for a primary. Two percent may be extremely small, but 42 percent is all that great either.

Wouldn’t it be great if instead of having to choose between really horrible turn-out and depressing turn-out, we could find a way to get more people participating?

Bergeson watch is over

A media something-or-other finally put finger to internet and saw that OSPI chief Terry B. is running again, so my vigil is over. Olympian Education Blog:

According to the Public Disclosure Commission, Bergeson’s committee filed its registration paperwork a few weeks ago, as did Richard Semler, who (according to our sister paper The Tri-City Herald) is the soon-to-be retiring superintendent of the Richland School District. Donald Hansler of Spanaway filed a campaign committee registration form in 2006, but nothing else since then.

Leave it to a blogger though, in this waining days of my watch, to take a close look at a couple of roots of the race (if this race were a tree…). Ryan at I Thought a Think:

The business community loves Terry Bergeson, because the business community gains personally from the higher standards of education that the WASL represents. The WASL is a very bottom line assessment, something that business leaders understand, and I don’t know that there’s anything that teachers or parents could say that would turn their heads to our way of thinking.

…

Terry’s biggest donations might come from the private sector, but her largest numbers of donors are those who work under her.

…

There are an awful lot of people around the state who have a personal stake in seeing Bergeson returned to office. They have history, cache, an in; however you want to put it. If a new wind blows their boat goes off course, and that’s when personal self interest kicks in and gets them to reach for their wallet.

Everything I’ve heard and seen speaks to the idea that Richard Semler is a good man. I’ve heard him talk about the how the testing system in Washington has gotten far away from any educational purpose, and he’s right. Living here in Eastern Washington, where we voted Tom Foley out of office when he was Speaker of the House, I should probably be more optimistic.

As things stand, though, Bergeson is racing with a Porsche while Semler hops behind on a pogo stick. And that’s why she’s going to be, once again, the Superintendent of Public Instruction.

My thoughts on this entire thing is that we should focus less on making employees and focus more on making citizens. But, I’m a liberal arts major, so you’d expect that.

Terry Bergeson IS RUNNING for reelection watch, day 24

Almost a month now and no one has noticed that she’s filing PDC reports, she’s running for re-election. Does she need to notice a press release for anyone to really figure this one out?

Read about people getting mad about math.

She has $25K in the campaign kitty.

Guess who knows she’s running? City of Olympia Mayor (for now) Mark Foutch and Paul Allen (yes, that Paul Allen) of Vulcan Capital. Because they donated to her campaign.

Sonntag, Inslee and public comments

State Auditor Brian Sonntag is going to hold a televised, teleconference with Washington State citizens. So says the first commenter at the Olympian on this:

How brave of this bureaucRAT . . . “Randomly chosen” participants. How ’bout a few town meetings across the state at your expense, Mr. Sonntag? If you have any balls to do it…

Seemingly pointing to the difference between an event where the participants choose themselves (by choosing to attend) and an event where the participants are chosen at random. Sonntag’s version is more interesting to me.

Daryl over at Hominid Views had a similar experience with Jay Inslee and enjoyed it.

Gov. Gregoire recently finished a series of forums that the Olympian commenter would have approved of (which also included a random panel at another level), but when your main group of participants is self-chosen, I’m wondering if your just getting a room full of axe-grinders.

The difference with Sonntag’s version is that it will be televised, apparently broadening the reach of the project. It would be interesting if they did this twice a year, just for consistency.

Interesting note is that Elway Research is behind this projects as well as the governor’s recent tour.

Washington Dems Strawpoll: Edwards, Obama and then Kucinich

Dennis Kucinich is doing pretty well in an email straw poll to Washington State Democrats, coming in third ahead of Hillary Clinton. Edwards is leading the pack, following closely by Obama of Illinois:

John Edwards 780
Barack Obama 713
Dennis Kucinich 511
Hillary Clinton 505
Undecided 280
Bill Richardson 234
Joe Biden 112
Chris Dodd 27
Mike Gravel 6

These are “early” numbers since the voting is ongoing here. Go here before December 14 if you want to express your preference.

If you ask me, I wouldn’t vote in this poll since it seems to be a way to collect your data.

« Older posts Newer posts »

© 2026 Olympia Time

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑